Everybody ignored Baywatch. My guess is that few have played it. Yes, the theme is horrible! Having to look at hot chicks on the back glass is just awful Seriously the theme ends up being a generic lifeguard or rescue them and doesn't bother me at all even though I hate the show.

It has a lot of great shots and the modes are varied. 7 modes, 1 wizard mode, 2 video modes, and a really good multiball.

Definitely the best bang for the buck of your original list. The only bad part is the modes don't stack and they some of them aren't worth The risk vs reward.

GoT has great stackable modes and I agree with others that the strategy involved with how to attack the game is amazing.

STtNG or Judge Dredd are great mode based games. JD's wizard mode is a bit of a let down though I agree.

No one mentioned Addams Family? Maybe you already own that one. Been a while since I read OP.