I hate to be Mr Price Tag but there are some good deals and quite a few not so good deals on those shelves:
Deals:
Rittenhouse Rye looks like $23 - load up
Sazarac Rye at $31 is about right but its often out of stock in Delaware/PA/MD still performs at or above its price - load up
Widow Jane $60 that bottle could run 75 or 80 here. i see its on sale but even at regular price i don't buy it. at that price i add to collection - load up ( i have never had this but for this price i would take my chances
Eagle Rare $33 usually between 30-36 so i would def buy those on the shelf - i would get that bottle if you don't normally see ER10 on shelves
RRoses SB selling less than $40 -i would take that too!
Bad deals i might still take:
ECBP probably the best bourbon on the shelf @75$ is easily $10-$15 more than i pay. might still be worth getting if money not a concern
Bad deal i'm def passing on:
Angels Envy about $10 more than we see around here. i usually pass on their stuff , its good but its probably overpriced everywhere
No values here:
$20 too much for Old Overholt still see it for $15
$29 too much for Larceny - generally $23
$29 too much for BT - usually about 22-23 here
The standards, knob creek, 4 Roses, Woodford, Makers all seem to be priced right around what i would expect