TOTAN and LOTR would not be my selection. Maybe it would be a few years ago but I find those games too easy to play now. If I'm picking a game I need last-ability.
I love the looks of WOZ, but I find myself getting bored of it for some reason.
I want to choose JJPOTC, but I'm afraid of the constant maintenance. I've heard this as an issue from a number of sources that I trust. If I know I could get this pin and have 0 problems, this would be my pick. But if not, JP2 is my selection.