I've owned both games....It is surprising the value POTC commands considering the amount of them that were made compared to FGY. If you really want the HUO FGY....and they aren't willing to budge on that trade offer, I would take it. Not a lot of FGY machines floating around, and the fact its a HUO model is even more special. The FGY I had was a HUO machine as well....my 2 cents
Jeff (jar155) doesn't really like POTC, so you know his thoughts are genuine.....at least that's what I heard many times on his podcast