Quoted from nate1981s:I am sorry this happened to you. I was taken a few months ago for $45 and I was pissed and I was the buyer! The company faked a USPS tracking number and that's all paypal needed to close my claim. The real question is how did they find another USPS tracking number to my town to fake it. The post office said they have not seen this before. The weight of item was way off and was to a different address and person. No way of opening the paypal dispute again or speaking with someone. I can't imagine how pissed you are. If you know how to fool paypal it seems scammers can make a lot of money. I will avoid now at all costs. Did you manage to find a phone number and actually speak to someone?
I had this exact thing happen to me. What they do is ship something to the same zip code as you and that's all Paypal and eBay needs to close the claim and say it was delivered. It took a while but I finally proved the package was not delivered to MY address. I actually had to get a three way phone call going with a rep from Paypal AND FedEx! It was a nightmare and was for a lot of money but ultimately worked out, but yeah, this is the new scam, ship something to ANY house in your zip area