$1500 is not terrible, but it is above average (for now). $1200 would be nice, but we're only talking a $300 delta. You've got two very nice things going for you: a low-fade cabinet, and lower playfield Mylar. Many player Paragons have significant wear in the 1-10 inserts, and that's a lot harder to stomach (and fix) than that kickout wear. Regardless of the kickout wear you have more going for you than not.
The repro playfield are coming; pre orders are being accepted at CPR (http://www.classicplayfields.com/order.html). Paragon pins will get harder to find as a result.
BTW, great choice of pins. I have a nice one, and a second basket case with an NOS playfield waiting for the full restoration.