Quoted from tomdrum:Did a little research on a confidence pool:
The format of how a confidence pool works is very simple. Let’s say, there are 16 games being played on week 1 of the NFL season. Your task is to pick a heads-up winner in each matchup (the spread does not matter) and rank each matchup from 1-16. Putting 16 beside a matchup means that is your most confident selection, and putting 1 beside a potential winner means it is a game that you have the least confidence in. Points are rewarded based on the confidence you give each matchup, 16 obviously being the highest amount of points you can receive from a win and 1 being the least.
I like that format because everyone would be involved till the end of the regular season.
I *love* confidence pools and have been playing in them with my poker buddies for over 10 years now. Just to note though, they're almost always pick 10 games and rank them 10-1 on confidence. A lot of the season has bye weeks and there are 14 games, not 16, and it takes long enough to pick 10 and weight them every week, more than that would be like a part-time job. It really does double or triple your picking time when you have to rank by confidence, but it's really a lot more interesting that straight pick'em. We've been using officefootballpool.com all these years, not exactly visually exciting but works well.
edit: Also, we play confidence with point spread. w/o point spread makes it too easy.