Quoted from VacFink:That was my point of contention. The 'historian' didn't seem to support any of the reasoning for how those conclusions could be even remotely reasonable. Maybe the show's edited to produce that effect and there was more in that discussion. However I didn't gather from the responses that that was really happening.
Since idolitry would not have been something the very Christian and very zealous Templar would likely allow, that connection just seems totally off the rails, and unsupported by any evidence in terms of travelers to this part of the world, in that time frame. Wild conjecture in my opinion, but guess the series will vet it out.
You mentioned other threads art, would be interested in seeing those if you can share here. I'm not putting my info down into another discussion venue, but might like to spectate a bit as I'm keenly interested in the topic.
The view and creation of Templars, is not without debate.
Common statements were to protect the Christian Pilgrims who wish to visit Jerusalem.
While this was inherently true at the end of the history, in the beginning it was about the oral history of the Temple Treasures
hidden in the tunnels under the city (Copper Scrolls), as well as a return to their homeland.
The original movement, funding, etc, is in one theory, originally underwritten by the Jewish population,
and than propagandized through the Church, to become true. What was brought back, soon lead to the Protestant movement and indulgences.
Christianity during the years of say 800-1300 in the period of the Templars, was very different than we think today, and changed again, in the 1500's to the
King James Bible, which changed everything, yet again.
An easy example is the Star of David, found on churches, and is a Christian Symbol, prior to it being a Jewish symbol. (even the word "Jew", did not appear in writing until the middle 1700's!)
No idiolatry, but hard to say if this cross, say found in Jerusalem, would have been considered an ancient Christian Cross...a relic, thought to have been from Christs time. The peddling of Christ relics, took on full business after Queen Helena went on tour in 300 AD, so in the souk, as today, one can find a table with real and fake pottery, crosses, oil lamps, etc.
A bunch of dialogue I have is with personal friends..puzzle guys on this, but heres some for much more:
http://www.treasurenet.com/forums/oak-island/
https://www.reddit.com/r/OakIsland/
http://forum.oakislandtreasure.co.uk/