This show is pretty amazing, not necessarily for what they find or don't find, but the effect it has on people. It seems to draw people to it that want to make comments like "They're not going to find anything!" or "They're milking it for money!" You seem to be missing anything of value from the show but still want to go negative on it. why watch if you don't enjoy it?
I'll tell you what I see. This is just my opinion, what do I know? The story from 1795 is suspicious, but we know around 1849 a reporter was out there writing about the digging at the time. Old timers at the time, told him the story and it was printed in the paper in 1849, so we know there was at least a Hoax, or some reason people were searching at that time. They haven't found anything much of value that entire time, but the real story is how it consumes people's lives. Some of them are doing it for the money, but a lot of them have done it for the mystery, which is the same reason people watch it.
The real story of the show isn't whether or not they'll find anything, it's why they even want to (or you want to watch it). Dan Blankenship went there in the 1960's, decided he thought there was a cave 250 feet below ground nowhere near the money pit, decided he wanted to dig down to it, then with the help or 1 or 2 people dug a hole 10 feet wide and 230 feet deep to Bedrock. Then he drilled a passage 21" wide through the bedrock into the cave, and dove 200 feet underwater, through that narrow passage into the cave, and walked around. He did this on TEN SEPERATE OCCASIONS. Why? .... because he wanted to. Just the sheer amount of determination that would take is mind blowing to me. I think he was crazy, but I respect the guy.
This is how skyscrapers were invented. Some guy like Dan Blankenship decided he wanted to put his house on top of somebody else's house.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The story's probably nonsense, but the only way they'll know if it is is by doing exactly what the brothers are doing. I admire that they were able to hook the History channel into funding all this. If you think Marty is paying for anything on Oak Island you must have stopped watching in the first season. It's still consistently one of the History Channel's top rated shows... As a matter of fact, if you check out a graph at say this link : https://showbuzzdaily.com/articles/showbuzzdailys-tuesday-3-8-2022-top-150-cable-originals-network-finals.html
Last week it was the #3 rated show on cable (On Tuesday Night), behind two news programs. They're killing it. And they're 9 seasons in. I don't like the History channel's production of the show or the horrible narrator but the brothers I admire, and I don't think either one of them would lie or misrepresent something.
So I'll keep watching, it's interesting to me even though they don't find anything. I like when they show the history of what other 'searchers' did and the remains of their work still on the island, even though most of them have passed on. That's cool to me.
A lot of you seem smart enough to figure out it's a Hoax but not smart enough to figure out the real story is about two brothers doing something just because they want to, even if smug know it alls laugh at them.