Quoted from RobT:In my quest to find another show that might approach the greatness of Breaking Bad (a search that has been in vain so far) I have started watching Game of Thrones. Highly rated show and many here seem to really love it.
I think it is fairly well done, but I just can't get into it that much. I've watched the first 5 episodes. I can't quite say that I'm hooked. In fact, I think I'd rather watch Arrow than Game of Thrones!
I thoroughly enjoy Game of Thrones, and I'm not really into the fantasy genre. My 22-yr-old son and I watch it together live on Sunday nights every time a new episode airs. (That is a very rare occurrence in our three-TiVo household.) I will, however, readily admit that the series is a "slow burn", so you probably need to watch all the way through the end of the first season to really get hooked.
The biggest problem with critiquing Game of Thrones as a television series is that it is still in production, and the book series upon which the television series is based (A Song of Ice and Fire) is still being written. Given the age of George R.R. Martin -- the 66-yr-old author of the books -- and how long the series has been in development (18 years), there is a very real possibility that he may pass on before the books are finished, and if the source material is incomplete, the long-term impact of the TV series could be greatly diminished.
I can say one thing with confidence, though. IMHO, several individual episodes of Game of Thrones (e.g., And Now His Watch is Ended, The Rains of Castamere) are every bit as memorable to me as some of the best episodes of The Wire (Middle Ground, Final Grades), The Sopranos (College, Pine Barrens), and Breaking Bad (Ozymandius).