In the end I vote JJP. Star Wars is just too juicy with video to do it elsewhere. JJP is the king of video in pin integration, the Hobbit shows that. Mostly though, I want Lawlor to design it and to give us something truly cool, new and innovative. Pat is a genius and I know he could design something new that would be truly epic.
If Stern gets it, it should go to Steve for a fast battle type pin, but we already have the new Star Trek for that..
Stern would do OK, but I don't trust them to give me the value I want in this title. JJP is more bang for the buck, and by the time they would be doing this, they should be rolling along at full steam, much faster than they are now (if they aren't by then, they wouldn't be around to do it anyway).