Bunch together similar games (like MM or AFM) and then get rid of one of the two. Also try to figure out what is played least in your lineup and target those as well.
If it were just me picking a lineup without regards for family or friends I would axe MM, AFM, and Spiderman, however I know family and friends would love AFM, so I'd keep it. To fill in that third spot I'd probably pick between Twilight Zone and Indiana Jones, with IJ being the one more likely to leave.