Great list of games! So subjective but my taste, I'd part w/ Rollergames, TWD then Spiderman or AFM in that if you get the itch, at least you'll be able to get an AFMR or SpideyVE within the foreseeable future.
Personally, I'd swap the RZ preoder for an Alien or TBL. I wouldn't sell your WOZ because having those two JJP games next to each other will be kinda cool. But I guess the same could be said about having Spooky games side by side.. so I'm talking myself in circles now. The dilemma is real!
Using audits - I'd tracked which games get the most play over a period of time (90 days) and I used that to weigh my decision as to what goes and what stays.