Just stumbled upon this topic, great thread!
Creature is one fo the most amazing games ever. The sounds, the theme, the shots, it has it all IMO.
NGG is just plain fun, one of the toughest and coolest shots in pinball, the hole in 1
Finallly Fish tales, super fast, rhythm machine. The theme, music and call outs on this are amazing, can get old for some folks but i love it, keep coming back for more!
2. Fish Tales
But this is my feeling