If you've had the NGG for a while and have played it as much as you're going to play it... get the Safecracker. Safecracker is a ton of fun in a collection. BUT, it's limited for gameplay and after a few weeks you've seen all you're going to see. NGG has a lot more longevity going for it.

I prefer Safecracker, but it does not fit into a normal pin lineup. And it looks odd/bad if you take the two "wings" off. So you pretty much have to have the right spot (some odd corner maybe?) to fit it in. If you like your NGG (which sounds like a good one) you should probably keep it.

Ive owned just about every PL game made (the good ones, not the crappy ones he did at Stern ).

Safecracker had the absolute SHORTEST longevity/replay-ability of any game I've had.

Better play safe cracker first I only played it once and couldn't make it thru one game I was so bored, the only other game that was worse to me than safe cracker was gottliebs strikes n spares.

check out SC on pinball arcade to get a feel for it before thinking about picking one up.

In a collection of 24, machines SC would go very well. NGG are everywhere, and it's a good game for guests but gets old.

My vote is for SC. I had a Gofers for a while but it got old quick. Couldn't stand the music and annoying call outs. Plus all the mechanical noise the game makes, things are constantly slamming up and down. The layout is really fun to shoot, maybe my favorite Lawler game shot wise but it's really gimped by the rushed software. Super annoying when Buzz gets stuck up for the rest of the ball or when you hit a hole in one shot and it doesn't count for anything.

I got rid of my Gofers and haven't thought aboot it since. It's a fun game, but it's a bit of a mess. SC is more a museum piece for sure, but there's nothing like it. NGG is like a lot of things, and easy to find. Why? Because people get sick of it and sell it and don't miss it