Owned all four and have two currently. In my mind unless you are a higher end advanced to elite player the game is a dud. I like rulesets and figuring them out but this one was nails on a chalk board. hated it. LotR is one of the best theme captures out there but the PotD kills this game. Couldnt get past that so I will put that third of the four. Iron Maiden is too early but easily comes in second. I want to keep pushing the start button. Met is a nirvana pin for me and while deep, is attainable for me and the rule sheet isnt like calculus.