I bought a Nip It with a bad Gator Solenoid. It is known to be unobtainium. Chas10e turned me on to the world of laminated solenoids. With lots of googling and reading datasheets, I found a solenoid that had the same mounting locations and the same width actuated arm. It is used on furnaces. When I removed the original solenoid, I found the same part number with a 1973 manufacture date. The part number is 2536-M-1 and currently made by Dormeyer.

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00N3HPO9O/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o00_s00

Attached a picture of the new solenoid installed. Also had to manufacture a new roller since one was missing.

IMG_3490 (resized).jpg

I can't. I already disposed of it. Sorry.

Here is a shot of the unit installed, before the new solenoid and roller. I had to disassemble each pivot and clean with alcohol.

IMG_3161 (resized).jpg

As I mentioned in that post, the 2nd picture is before I removed the old part. The solenoid a 120v solenoid. Same identical part number.

The picture in the link you posted also has the same base part number. (2536)

Ken, same part number. It is the continuous duty cycle solenoid. http://disti-assets.s3.amazonaws.com/testco-inc/files/datasheets/13220.pdf