NIN, hands down. I love their industrial, hard-driving sound. Nothing against Aerosmith, which I also love, but don't feel they work as a pin. Just my opinion.
Shoot ball into the Pretty Hate Machine to start Happiness In Slavery multiball (see DMD video of poor bastard getting drilled, poked and tortured to death. Will include adult settings, obviously). Also can include gritty, dark, dirty artwork like the dreariness of Closer and cage from Wish. Sub playfield Downward Spiral toy accelerates ball in a concentric fashion.
Endless possibilities.