Wish would have to be there...better than Reptile. I'd also take Heresy over Reptile too. But Wish is the whole reason I started listening to them. Now, I mostly enjoy his softer stuff, but have grown to appreciate all of his "noise" as I've gotten older. Of the 2, I'd get NIN over Aerosmith, but Aerosmith would have a much broader appeal...plus, you couldn't censor NIN enough without ruining it.