Wow, I couldn't think of two titles that couldn't be more different. CFTBL is a more complete game with an old school feel, but I like NGG more.

Have both.. Like both.. If I had to choose, it would be Gofers...

NGG hands down to me.

For some reason I could never get into Creature. Too bad because I LOVE the theme.

Here's another one that makes me think of..........

shit_pickle.png

You forgot a "none of the above" catagory.

Have both--and my vote goes to CFTBL (by a nose).

Also love NGG...but CFTBL is a quintessential "just one more game" title for me.

Plus, seeing an original green hologram just makes it extra so cool for me (based on nostalgia reasons).

Traded NGG for Creech last summer. Tried to love Gofers but it just wasn't happening. Don't know why, but it just didn't trip that magical "fun" switch for me, too bad cuz NGG was in much nicer
condition.

But, Creech is a keeper. I may love it more than lamp...

Had both. Traded NGG away! Got tired of those smart-ass rats!!!

Well played Creature in the wild but not NGG. Based on what I've played on TPA NGG is my favorite table. For me If I had a choice for real machine it would be NGG because of that 'Hole In One' Shot. So satisfying.

CFTBL is my pick. I remember playing it when I was six.

Owned both and love the theme and old drive in stuff with CFTBL. Found game difficult and kept it for 2.5 years. NGG was the best family pin we ever owned and I regret selling it. Liked the humor and different modes. Guess if I had to choose would give NGG by a hair because I liked the game play and rules slightly better.

NGG is one of the best pinball machines ever along with Caddyshack being one of the best movies ever, IMHO. In terms of movie theme and pinball play its NGG for 18 holes.

Pool and a pond, pond would be good for CFTBL....natural spring water.

All the best....

Shit Pickle!

Played both own the CFTBL and vote it because of the theme. Love the ramps too!

Nearly an impossible choice if I had to make it, both great games that I hope to never have to get rid of.

"WRONG HOLE!"

It is 28-29 creature right now. Close

I've had CFTBL and I'd rather have a NGG.

If they would sharpen up the code on NGG it wouldnt even be a contest.

Sold my Creech and bought a NGG. 10x the fun.

Creech all the way...

Had a hard time getting into NGG... Creech is staying.

I think NGG is way more fun, but both are great pins.

I have a Creech and love it, I have played NGG and like it alot. My vote is Creech!

I went with Creech on this, although I like NGG too.

I have a Creature, and would be difficult to sell it. But NGG is on the top 5 list to get....I want both.

I absolutely positively love my gofers. I love them taunting me, being smart-alec, stealing my balls, the whole works. The light show is awesome, the slam ramp is fun, and there's nothing like sinking a hole in 1 on the first shot. I played the game virtually and was immediatley drawn to it, but didn't get the full experience until I actually got my real NGG. It's the first machine that has made me giggle and actually jump/cheer when I made a shot. I wuv it, and it is never going anywhere. The gofers and I are still in the honeymoon phase, but I play NGG at least every night and literally haven't put more than 5 games on any of my other machines since I got it.

I had the opportunity to get a nice CFTBL and passed. I've played it virtually and a few times in real life, but it just never clicked. I think it is a very pretty machine and I like the callouts, humor, and extra things you can do with the snack bar easter eggs. I just don't feel the need to own one.

CFTBL was my first pin, and I would never sell it. NGG is a great game too, but CFTBL is better!

I have both and I love Creech. NGG got boring to me quickly. I wan to sell it but I can't get any takers.

I bought a creech not long ago, I figured if I didn't like it,I would use it as trade bait down the road but it has grown on me so it's not going anywhere for now...

44 votes each and I justed voted for NGG to make it 45. In my opinion a far superior game to CFTBL with more speech, more humour and more lastability.

CFTBL is good, don't get me wrong but Gofers is my personal favourite.

I just got a CFBL last week. I've owned and played lot of NGG in the past. Both are excellent games, but for me right now CFBL wins only because it's fast and really damn challenging to get a good game out of it.

NGG for me. Tons of flow and intersting shots that are gratifying to make. The golf cart is bad ass. The gophers are pretty funny without over doing it. There are a lot of different modes that are cool to play. Color scheme is absolutely brilliant with blue ramps.

www.habosarcade.com/NoGoodGofers.htm‎

NGG for me. I think I must be missing something on CFBL. I just never really have enjoyed the game at all. I mean, beautiful artwork, theme, sound, tone, but the gameplay has just never enticed me. I feel I can't see half of my shots.

Had both. Sold both.

Bought back a NGG.

CFTBL is a awesome, classic game. Good music, callouts, etc.

But, for more pure playing enjoyment, NGG wins.

If I had a huge collection and wanted to fill out the "monsters" themes - I'd absolutely want to have it.... But in a small collection now- it doesn't make the cut.

I'm biased on this for quite a few reasons, but I will say this:

I've owned every regular production DMD game, and in the small collection that I've decided to keep, NGG is one of them. Another is Viper Night Drivin though, so what does my opinion matter

CFTBL is still a great game. Everybody has their own opinions and memories though.

Yes! and

Yes it was.

CFTBL

NGG is worthy of a code update. As it stands its a flat out fun to play pin and the hole in one shot was genius and well executed. I traded into mine and really like it. Its not a deep rules game but fast & fun.

Creech

Had both, sold both & would definitely like to have a NGG in the collection again - owned the NGG f/5 years & CFTBL for about 4.
Absolutely loved Creech's theme, art, sound package & music but Game play just didn't do it for me over time, fun but not as fast & flowing or as stackable mode wise as NGG - 2 Ball multi-ball was kind of a drawback as well (IMO).
Looked for a long time time to find a nice CFTBL (& did), NGG was part of a package buy to get a MB, figured I'd just sell the NGG but really liked the play & held onto it
NGG was sold to make room for a new Pin & I won't make that mistake again if I find a keeper (fold them up, rack-em & stack-em I say! 8-}) loved the flow, speed, jokes & especially those damn taunting Gofers.

Both are great Games but my vote goes to NGG.

Pin - K

www.KimballsPinballs.com

CFTBL

non pinball people love NGG.

Own both, and would never sell either. That said, if art/theme are excluded, NGG wins on overall gameplay. Tremendous flow and speed, furious action and mayhem, and was hands down the most fun machine in my collection until the arrival of AC/DC.

However, I highly value art and theme and nothing surpasses CREECH in those categories, not to mention the major nostalgia and Americana vibe. Also, nothing in NGG can match the tension/adrenaline of trying to qualify and collect the Super Jackpot. So intense!

As I've said before Creech can be a very polarizing game. It's pretty narrow in what you need to do which can turn some people off. Basically you just looking so save the sexpot form the creatures crotch over and over, and it's not an easy thing to do. But when you hit that Super you've really earned it. I've never gotten sick of it but I've never owned it either.

I voted for Creech even though I'm looking for a NGG as we speak....just had more experience with it. Even with that bastard snack bar shot that can get to you.

Is the creech hologram available or still made from unobtanium ?

NGG. CFTBL....dont get it.

Where are you located?

I swear, it is ALWAYS 50% each. I guess they're quite equal, then.