Go with what the family wants. Period, full stop, end of discussion. Will your family love it in 2 years? Probably not. Will they like any pin you buy in two years? Not likely. Hell, over half the of the people on this forum turn over over half of their games (or just don't play them if room isn't an issue) in two years. Get the game they like, enjoy the time together doing something together as a family...it ain't worth stressing over!