You mention you are a Hobbit fan. In my game room kids are really drawn to that one and you can find them for $6500 (one is currently listed for that), so if the cost is an issue that is probably the one to buy. I also have a WOZ and think it is a better game but it isn't as much of a bargain on the 2nd hand market. I don't have as much time on DI - it shoots nice but the theme isn't for everyone. Too early to judge POTC but it will be the most expensive and hardest to find, at least initially.