Nice review, nobody can say you guys are shills nor was it overly mean or critical, this is what an objective review should be like. This is probably the best review you guys have done to date, it was so informative and the best part was when you two describe the payoff/satisfaction quotient of certain shots. This kind of thing makes us (the audience) relate to the review or thought process a little more. After all, playing a game is still very subjective. Props to you both you man, you guys are really getting good at this......and it only took 73 tries.
PS: love the cut scenes with DP...
PPS: Greg, the thing you were struggling to name, the "It Factor" or whatever that was missing IMO is theme integration....maybe you guys need to rename the "Theme" category to "Theme Integration" instead. In any case it kind of ties into what you were saying, is this a generic comic book pin or a DP comic book pin? Do you feel it's catching the vibe of DP when playing it? I hate to say it but it's the World under glass thing. It just didn't capture the essence of DP, for comparison use WOZ.