First my condolences on you Aunt Dorie. Next congrats on an allready nice linup. Since i played all the machines which you are considering i would for my taste go with either the TNMT or Jurassic Park. Elvira is also very good but in my taste is don't think it would be a keeper. If you are open to another suggestion and if you like the music Iron Maiden is also a brilliant game. A bit prejudice on my side since i just bought a NIB premium version of that. Hope you can decide which machine will be joining your collection.

Jurassic Park, walk-off grand slam, requiescat Aunt Dorie, mic drop.

You have the same game twice with Star Trek and Spiderman. Pick one and move one. Then buy TWD and JP or Elvira.

I agree. Out of the games listed, this is the one I would pick.

So now, the why...

Wonka - Sure, it will have some hardcore fans, but I'm not one of them. I find it boring and slow. Unless I have to play it in competition again, I doubt I'll ever play another game on one. If there was any other available machine to play, I'd play the other.

Elvira - I'm not a fan, but I have not played later updates. It just wasn't engaging for me. And this is one game where the "stops" nature of it really hurts it. It overall feels like a weak effort.

TMNT - Ok, I'll admit it, I have not played it.

JP - By far the best of the bunch (just my opinion). Rules are fun, and interesting. I find the shots different enough to be intriguing. If it was my money, this is the game I'd pick.

#heist by Multimorphic
And once you have your P3 system you can swap in whatever playfield you feel like in under two minutes. Great way for the space challenged to have more games.

just my opinion in this order

JP
TMNT
Elvira
Wonka

YES, listen to this. Sell spidey and grab one of each and add a NIB JP or TMNT. Enjoy.

I have had an Elvira LE for about 6 months now. Even with all the code updates, it will be the first to go if I ever need to make room. It's a great game and guests absolutely love it but it has already grown a little old for me. I understand the need to compliment your current collection. I have Iron Maiden Premium sitting next to a Metallica Pro. Two awesome games that play entirely different. I have played a lot on both TMNT and JP and have also been considering adding one or the other to the collection but I might need to flip a coin. I have only played a couple games on WW so no opinion except for what I have heard from others. I agree with RustyLizard and woody76 on limiting yourself by not having a SS... and selling Spidey. In fact, maybe I should sell Elvira and add both JP and TMNT.

Your whole collection is like pure flow games. JP will offer nice balance because it’s a more “technical” shooter with a super unique layout.

Second vote for Heist! Once you are bought into the P3 ecosystem, it's awesome being able to expand your library of games for relatively little money without needing more space (all the play fields can be stored under the P3 and your other machines). And every new release and feature for the platform you benefit from as an owner. If you decide a few moths after Heist to buy the Cosmic Cart Racing playfield, you can jump in to internet connected head to head races for free, which are an absolute blast and such a welcome bit of competitive pinball in a time when we can't do it in public. Lexy Lightspeed - Escape From Earth is also a criminally underrated game, and if you have a family, all the games available for the Cannon Lagoon playfield are a big hit with casual and young players.

Quite simply, if you have $10k and room for only one more game, it's a no brainer to jump into the P3 ecosystem.

Wonka boring and slow?Really and you've played it?

P3 covid.png