The Houdini that Ben described, is exactly the kind of stuff we were throwing together on the MG that went to the NW show last summer. Those Houdini round headed screws to hold the ramp (the left one screwed in at an angle) instead of flat screws, the subways to nowhere, the mechs slapped on with no room in criss-cross ramps for a ball to make it through - those were the kinds of things pdxmoney and I were dealing with on MG
MG was a mess. Hell, the monitor brackets were too long, the PF wouldn't go all the way in and under the monitor!!!! I "solved" that one - we reversed and flipped the brackets, gained 3 inches and the PF fit - but that's a non-engineer coming in at the 23rd hour to fix the PF not fitting below the screen!! Too many examples to list - but random rivets and other screws put in "wherever", "I'll worry about putting the Liger motor in later, I want that to spin eventually", "I guess we have to move that back plastic to the get PF in all the way" - WTF? Part of the reason I helped at all was to see what was possible (or not) and at least get the game out of the lab and into the light of day
So, all that to say I'm not shocked at all by Ben's findings on Houdini - all so familiar to when I was putting in random screws on MG - its so sad and stomach churning.
I guess the good news is that Houdini got out of the lab quickly. The feedback was quick and harsh, but at least AP already hired Joe based on what they saw - at least Houdini is out there now. Dhaval had no intention of going to Expo when I talked to him 8 weeks ago. I told him he better show up, if he announces anything before the show, he has to make it to the show.
When I visited AP in August, and talked to DHaval in the parking lot, pre-scott, pre-Joe (perhaps only Dhaval at that time??), DV told me he knew about Jpop or "had heard of his troubles in the past" - so have no doubts that AP knew exactly what John was (and wasn't). DV may have been naive about what Jpop showed him on MG, and whether it was playable. It would take no time at all for Joe or Ben, or likely any of us, to take one look at Houdini (running a script of blinking lights on an arduino ?!) and know it wasn't anything near a prototype.
Unless Jpop did a ton of reworking on MG, including inventing the mechs that had yet to be made (but there were CAD models in his PC), within the past months since June 2015 - the MG that Dhavani has in his hands, probably can't be produced - Chris@Cointaker or the Mr68 may have more details of how far it is along. But I've helped assemble that 50% box of somewhat flipping parts and mostly? done code - and there was a lot of engineering left to go (I mean really - the clearance of crossing ramps was blocking balls?).
But based on the Pinball Magazine's J Joosten podcast and the Expo interviews - can we expect to see any MG by year end, let alone all of them?
I'm so sorry for all the people screwed by this - don't mean to bring up bad memories of the MG reveal last year - I do agree that there is now a better than 0% change as compared to August, but the Expo reveal was not encouraging. Having some capital and some bodies on board is much better than just a few weeks ago - however, its hard to put this at more than a 1% chance yet.
Cointaker, GLM or Mr68 - hopefully got something better than what we've seen, heard or was shared at Expo.