This gets my vote haha. Good luck with the decision. I'd jettison T2 and Strange Science myself, but I think you already knew that.

T2 & BR.

BR is a pirate theme and that's cool; and that's where the coolness ends.

I would keep only T2 and Who Dunnit, but i don't think that can help you

Sell the two that you play and/or enjoy the least. Nothing else matters.

Any pin friends nearby that can take a couple for while? Then rotate them in a month or so, and after a few months you’ll know which ones you could live without long term.

I have no kitchen table two pins there instead. And my girl is ok with that. So I vote make more room some where.

Looking at your currently owned games, I couldn't get Tri-zone and Time Warp to the curb fast enough over what you are considering parting with. I perfer EMs over many of my Solid State games but those early SS WMS games are just so darn bad!

But that's just me (and you did ask )

Otherwise, I would dump Pinbot and Black Rose.

I would sell Black Rose and T2. Pinbot is a classic and hard to find in decent condition, Who Dunnit is underrated and a blast to play, and Strange Science is just weird enough to stick around. I find T2 to be incredibly boring over time. With the jackpots being tied to the gun, it takes away most of the "pinball" action. Plus, once you get good at it, the only way you score big is through the gun and I really don't think it's that exciting. Black Rose is not a bad game either, I just don't think it compares to the others you listed. The cannon is neat, but again, once you've seen it couple of times it tends to break up the gameplay enough that all you want is for the ball to come back into play. Good Luck. The good news is that you won't have a hard time selling any of the games on your list because they are all pretty sought after and they all fall in the sweet spot of moderately priced, but excellent games.

Whodunnit would be my choice. It's not that good, and it's worth he most so you'll get around $2500-3K of spending money. I know you didn't ask but every game on that list would be pretty expendable to me, maybe chum the waters with a bunch of FS ads and see what bites.

I would think T2 would be both the easiest to sell, and the easiest to get again if you want it later.

Some don't like using the gun, but it was a way to integrate the DMD technology that was new to pinball at the time. T2 went toe-to-toe with Street Fighter at its peak back in the day for quarters - the only pin at the time on that level - and shooting the gun in the video mode was definitely part of the "cool" factor.

Your results may vary.

download (resized).jpg

Tell her when she cleans out her side of the closet, you'll get rid of the machines. If your wife is like mine, I have about 2 ft of closet space and she has the other 10.

I'll buy your pinbot if it's in nice shape.

T2 - Was never a huge fan. It's decent, but for a DMD game, it plays like a system 11 game. With that said, there are a number of system 11 games that I have more fun playing than T2.

Black Rose - It never interested me, personally. I think it would make the most money out of the other pins you listed.

I really like Who Dunnit, plus it's a good party game based on my experience. Pinbot is a classic. Strange Science is a kooky theme and I like those type of games.

like what was said before, whatever ones you play the least are probably the obvious choice. thats how i decided to sell my last pin. just cause it looks cool or whatever dont matter when you need room for something you will enjoy PLAYING. if i had to pick two of those, strange science and who dunnit.

I will add he has the nicest BR I’ve seen.

any of them
apart from Strange Science, the others are easy to find if you do sell it and then regret

so, unless a game is mint, put them all on the market, see what sells first

I would get rid of Black Rose or Who Dunnit? The novelty wears off fast. I have been trying to trade or sell mine with no luck. It will take forever to get rid of, by that time you will be ready for it to leave. I would keep Strange Science especially if it's in good shape. Would be hard to replace.

I would bounce them all out. That changes your perspective on everything in a good way. You can always backtrack and buy all of these titles again. Don't give it another thought. I just bought White Water for the 3rd time! When it wasn't around I didn't miss it. Available real estate in the house becomes the most important commodity for me. A lot of great machines out there but only so much room unless you own a barn or an empty warehouse which I don't. Good luck!

I would list everything but Strange Science and sell what sells first and second.

That is what I'm doing aside for one that has nostalgic value.

Picking up a new job which is going to suck up all my time.. so my pin fixing hobby will be effectively on hold for a year minimum if not for several.

I've always thought T2 to be extremely boring. For the other I think I would sell Black Rose that game has just never really done much for me either.

I thought this was a weight lose thread.