Power off.
Disconnect P2 and Ball In Play displays.
Power up with P1, P3 and P4 connected. Note condition.
Power off.
Disconnect P1 and connect P2.
Power up with P2, P3 and P4 connected. Note condition.
Disconnect P2 and connect Ball In Play.
Power up. Note condition
This process may reveal a bad display, and also gets the cables reseated.
If you are still having the problem, swap cables between displays, then swap them end-to-end making sure the red stripe is to PIN 1 on both ends.