Medieval Madness- remake or original ?
Monster Bash - remake or original
Pirates - Stern or jjp ?

LTG : )

Crap. LTG just made my post for me while I was typing.

What did he pay for them, that will give you a starting point. Love these ads that selling someone else's machines, for a friend BS. The guy owns 5 pins but has no clue of the price some more BS

Wish I were closer! (I kid, I'm about 20 minutes away)

I'd suggest using the market archive to gather some data.

That said, if he wants to sell me Medieval Madness or Monster Bash for $4,000 I'll be right over!

Condition, Condition, condition.
MM and MB, 7-8 k each.
POC , 6-7 k.
T2 - probably 5k.
Woz, 10-12k depending if it's fully working, 2.0 lights, gevea mods, etc. What version is it?
Pinside Market place is not very accurate anymore. Usually about 10-20% to low.
Most sell game and don't donate especially the greedy one's that sell a high end game and can't donate $25 bucks on a 12k sale.

I think you mean the suggested range. The archives should be pretty telling though for the last few months no?

OP, pay attention to prices that sold quickly and those higher priced pins that did not sell.

Nice originals will get him $10K+ no problem.

remakes took a toll on the B/W originals but i don’t think that much. Certainly hurt them 7 years ago when they were 12+k games and remakes could be had for way less. There is still a demographic who prefers an original and considering there are no active FS ads for MM in the marketplace i would be it would garner some attention. I’m not a price pumper nor the price police but i do think the originals, especially in nice condition, will command a higher price. That said if you listed either for 7k they would be halfway down the road before you hit save to post the ad haha.

If you look at archives you can tell which ads are contributing to the average. Ones that say not sold won’t (tho oddly are never still in the person’s collection) nor will ones that say sold (amount undisclosed). This could be because they were fishing and came up dry (25k? Sure..). Or they wanted to avoid the fees like eric said.

The ones that say sold (amount private) do. Just you dont know the actual price. It really is only the business of the buyer and seller, but does make it difficult to know wat games REALLY sell for. I’ve even seen people disclose a price lower than what i know it sold for my if someone i know bought it. Maybe just embarrassed at what they sold it for / paid for it. It has zero to do with the pinside fees, that is a fixed $ based on game tier.

You can always start High, no response, slowly lower.