Ok, so a few months ago, I walked into this guys place and he had pinballs to the walls. I never collected pins until that day, and ended up buying his data east simpsons for 2k. I didnt know what i was doing but he sold it to me. Well, then I bought a freddy off of him for 2100, again, assuming he knows what he is talking about and it was in ok shape. At the same time he said he an excellent tales from the crypt for 2500, so I gave him 400 to hold it and pay him off over time. I had never seen it. Well, know that I know better, I realize the simpsons is very rough, tons of play field wear, cabinet ok, but painted in several spots. Not worth 2k. That fine, I learned my lesson, chalk it up to my education. Well, i go to look at the Tales from the Crypt, and it is ROUGH! The drop targets immediately break upon playing, the coin door doesn't close, the cabinet is beat and plastics look like death. I tell him i am not paying 2500 for it. A few days pass i tell him i want the 400 back i put down because it wasn't as expected, and he tells me it was a security deposit and a commitment to buy. I have been arguing now with this guy. What would you do?