Quoted from kpg:Apparently around here the only kinds of pins that gets rave reviews have bash toys in the middle, a couple ramps on the left & right of the machine, coding by Dwight or Lyman, and maybe some ridiculous outlanes or flippers gapped a mile apart. I guess its a formula that works, and I don't mind it either- but instead of the same beer with a different name and label on the bottle, i'd like to add a bottle of whiskey to my collection which is why TH will fit in nicely w/ my Sterns
I don't think there's any identifiable common thread between highly rated games on Pinside. Coding by Lyman is in just over half, but there's still variety in that aspect.
1. Medieval Madness
2. Twilight Zone
3. Monster Bash
4. Attack From Mars
5. Lord of the Rings
6. The Addams Family
7. Metallica
8. Indiana Jones
9. AC/DC
10. Tales of the Arabian Nights
3 have motorized stand up targets, 6 are fan layouts, 4 are non-fan, 6 are Lyman's games, none have wide flipper gaps, 3 bash toys, 4 mini playfields, 3 Stern, 7 B/W, 2 widebody games, 2 crappy art...
I think that it comes down to just games that are fun to play. I'm still surprised that TOTAN hangs on to such a high ranking. It's not a bad game, but it's very easy. It's by far the least challenging of the highly rated games.
And you know what? I have valid complaints about all 10 of those games, and I have great things to say about all 10. I don't think that me, or anybody else, expressing those opinions should make you feel threatened in any way. Twilight Zone is my all-time favorite game, but there are lots of people who hate on it for perfectly valid reasons according to their taste in pinball. They're not wrong. It's only problematic if they're going to blindly hate on a game they have no experience with. I would like to think that most people here aren't doing that with The Hobbit, Ghostbusters, or anything else.