Well, I just walked away from a game I went to buy for the first time ever. I went to look at the Surf Champ on Columbus Craigslist tonight. I was told the playfield and backglass were perfect; from the description I could tell the score motor was spinning. The pictures that I got via text were pretty grainy, but the playfield and backglass looked like they could be perfect, so it was worth checking out I thought.
Unfortunately, the playfield had wear in the middle between the bonus lights, and by the kickout. It was a solid 7. The backglass was probably an 8 - it had begun to flake ever so slightly, but was actually really nice overall. What really put me off was the fact that there was trash and mouse droppings down in the back of the cabinet. The lowest price I could get the guy to was $400. Probably a reasonable price, but I have too many projects in the works right now, and felt a bit disappointed by the condition.
Anyhow, it's an odd feeling to walk away from a game you intended to buy for the first time. Have any of you ever regretted walking on a game?