I own all three and they are staying.
Sell the dining room table and keep the pins.

Can you keep the extra pin with a storage solution? Since you don’t have a least fav, fold two games on end in the space of one pin currently. Now you have room for an AlienV plus you have two pins to rotate into your collection.

Iron Maiden is like chopping wood. Let it go

MET is a keeper for me

I have both- MET will go long before IM. As far as this post goes, sell SM

I was faced with the same dilemma. I still own met, and imdn. I do miss spidy though. Good luck with your choice it's a tough one.

Storage? Pffttt. I would lend one out to a friend or family and trade out every so often. You find out that way whether one is a good candidate to sell. I have 8 on loan right now since I can't have all my working ones set up at my house. I feel I'll be letting 2 of these go at some point in the future.

I sold Met Pro--missed it and bought a Premium.
I sold IMDN Premium--miss it and may buy a Pro down the road.
I sold Spiderman--did not miss it a single day.

Yea chopping wood while being hand fed caviar and getting a BJ from a supermodel.

Maiden is easily the best of those three!

LOL, right. If this is the case I've never had so much fun being a lumberjack. I love IMDN.

Then MET is a full-on lumberyard.

Unfortunately cannot confirm this.

Dump SM

I know exactly which game I’d sell. But that’s meaningless for you. You need more friends. I almost always have a few games at friends houses. They are people I trust, so it’s easy. I look at some pins as very long term ownership games. Games that I’ve lent out multiple times, and have loved when they circle back to me later. When I get them back, it’s like getting a new game, but one I know I love.

Never sell a game you love to play. Figure out another way to solve it. It also leaves your options open for later. Because eventually each game will get stale, and it will be time to sell it. If you sell it before that happens, you’ll just be looking for it later.

Me? I'd dump Scared Stiff.

Same. I did just that. It's certainly a looker, but the play for the price just isn't there.

I had a similar dilemma between Xmen, SM and MET. I love all 3 but I settled on selling XMen; I thought it would end up being SM but after weeks of playing all 3 I made the tough decision. It came down to the call outs just seemed to be less varied in Xmen (I don’t have a problem with the voice acting). SM can have some longer ball times but just has some nice flow and shots.

In your case I would let IMDN go if I owned it for similar reasons. I just don’t find the sound package interesting enough - I like the band but don’t love them and can go long times without hearing them. But that is me.

Good luck with the choice; it is a tough one.

Scared Stiff is the only game I ever sold that I miss. I know it isn’t difficult but it is always fun. I sold it to buy a Tron LE. Tough choice but I do love Tron.

Spiden Man has had it's day.

It's too much an easier playing title to be a forever keeper.

You'll never have trouble locating another SM if you wind up missing it too much.

Take out the center post and open up the outlines and tell me how easy SM is. Yes it is easier than some but as stated you need variety when it comes to a good collection. After playing TWD or IM you need something a little tamer.

Sell spider man. Like others stated, easier to find. Metallica and Iron Maiden better pins in my opinion and harder to find now.