My experience on Mr. Pinball sums up to the following:
There are legit sellers on the site.
They usually have a legit number on the ad.(I called one ad where the location was 20 miles north of me and had a colorado number).
If they are legit, the prices are waaaay over priced.
The best one I personally had was stringing a guy along for almost 10 days while he waited for me to go get walmart gift cards to send him. We texted almost every day. Told him I had the gift cards. He said great and wanted me to send them. I told him i was in the area and can pick it up and give him the cards. Never replied.