I think that games like MM and MB get over rated due to their one time scarcity. Maybe just in my area, but I never saw either of those games when they were current, and I'd hear people excitedly talk them up over the years. Now it seems like every time I walk into a place they have the full line up of MM, MB, AFM, Addams Family. I honestly don't like any of them all that much, and at this point prefer seeing some weirdo stuff I've never played.
Also LOTR is in the top ten? It's a good game but that surprises me.