1.Most Over Rated Pinball?
Adams family (fun game just does not rank high on my list)
2. Most Under Rated Pinball?
Star Wars Premium / LE
3. Most Over Priced Pinball?
Magic Girl
4. Best Value?
Pre owned Hobbit
What does Pinside think?
1.Most Over Rated Pinball.
TOM or TOTAN, beautiful with terrible rulesets
2. Most Under Rated Pinball
Mystery Castle in terms of top 100
3. Most Over Priced Pinball
BBB because PM is the better game and rarity is the only thing that makes BBB worth the money. If a few hundred more were made it would sell for Airborne money.
4. Best Value
Breakshot
Quoted from ASOA:1.Most Over Rated Pinball?
Adams family (fun game just does not rank high on my list)
2. Most Under Rated Pinball?
Star Wars Premium / LE
3. Most Over Priced Pinball?
Magic Girl
4. Best Value?
Pre owned Hobbit
What does Pinside think?
I can agree with the first three. Substitute WPT for best value.
Played about 20 rounds through an Adams family at a local bar. Sadly I have to agree I think its over rated.
Quoted from ASOA:What does Pinside think?
Pinside thinks someone needs to learn to spell. 
Medieval Madness is most overrated
Mustang is most underrated
BM66 SLE is most overpriced
A pre-owned WPT (or any WPT for that matter) is a best value
I think over rated and over priced go hand in hand as well as under rated and best value. Some that come to mind for over rated/priced are Adams, Monster Bash, CV, Dialed In, JJP POTC, Hobbit, AC/DC LE, TOM, Scared Stiff, TNA, Funhouse, Fathom-(I cant 'Fathom' what these are selling for nowadays), Tx-Sector, Guns and Roses, BTTF, Jetsons, Magic Girl, Data East Star Wars, Black Spiderman, Batman 66 SLE, Supreme and Congo is now on the edge of value v.s. cost, it has been trending upwards quickly.
Games that come to mind for being under rated or best value are T3, Star Wars Premium/LE, Ghostbusters Premium/LE, Barb Wire, Black Rose, Wh20(under valued imo), X-Men Magneto, Transformers LE, TFTC, JP, STTNG, WOF, I500(Super Fun/under rated), Earthshaker, Whirlwind, WPT, Shadow, NGG and CP & BSD & FT are now on the edge of value v.s. cost, all trending upwards quickly.
Overrated - Dialed In
Underrated - Rolling Stones
Overpriced - all above $8000
Best Value - Black rose
I feel that every pinball machine ever made is both overrated and yet underrated, while a good value but at the same time a ripoff.
Also I’d like to point out that saying a game like Addams Family or MM is overrated is like saying the Beatles or U2 are overrated: at some point something is just so popular your “hot take” opinion just doesn’t fucking matter.
Quoted from CrazyLevi:I feel that every pinball machine ever made is both overrated and yet underrated, while good value but at the same time a ripoff.
Damn, you should run for public office.
Quoted from CrazyLevi:I feel that every pinball machine ever made is both overrated and yet underrated, while a good value but at the same time a ripoff.
I’m easily confused and ready to vote.
Levi for Senate!!! 
Overrated - Metallica
Underrated - Mystery Castle (seconded)
Overpriced - BM66SLE
Best Value - X Files (I've found it twice for under $2000 in the last couple years, but it might be going up lately)
Quoted from CrazyLevi:your “hot take” opinion
Heh, out of all the posts, only one stands out with this attitude. It's just lists from pinheads wanting to shoot-the-pinball-shit. Why so ornery? Someone step on your toe with their selections? Go ahead, post yours, you'll feel better!
Quoted from CrazyLevi:Also I’d like to point out that saying a game like Addams Family or MM is overrated is like saying the Beatles or U2 are overrated: at some point something is just so popular your “hot take” opinion just doesn’t fucking matter.
Forgive me. What the hell was I thinking?! 
Quoted from Vino:I’m easily confused and ready to vote.
Levi for Senate!!!
My climb to power begins...
Underrated: Mustang Pro
Value: Mustang Pro
WTF. It’s the only game I’m playing right now. Granted, I’ve only had it a little more than a week, but I’m really enjoying it. I understand why it has a bad rap, but in my collection, it fits like a glove. Normally the honeymoon lasts about 2 days in my house, but this one is different. I never would have thought this game is this fun.
The Mustang at Flipout this year at the very least had the "Kickstart my Heart" song pasted into the gearshift multiball. That was good cheesy fun. It may have had the "full works" done as per this thread:
https://pinside.com/pinball/forum/topic/mustang-pinball-music
Quoted from DaveH:Underrated: Mustang Pro
Value: Mustang Pro
WTF. It’s the only game I’m playing right now. Granted, I’ve only had it a little more than a week, but I’m really enjoying it. I understand why it has a bad rap, but in my collection, it fits like a glove. Normally the honeymoon lasts about 2 days in my house, but this one is different. I never would have thought this game is this fun.
Quoted from DaveH:Underrated: Mustang Pro
Value: Mustang Pro
WTF. It’s the only game I’m playing right now. Granted, I’ve only had it a little more than a week, but I’m really enjoying it. I understand why it has a bad rap, but in my collection, it fits like a glove. Normally the honeymoon lasts about 2 days in my house, but this one is different. I never would have thought this game is this fun.
Cool to hear another pinhead has discovered the joys of Mustang's gameplay! Try playing a Premium/LE if you ever get a chance - it's even more fun (and consequently even more underrated).
Most Overrated: TOTAN
Most Underrated: Dirty Harry
Most Overpriced: Batman 66
Best Value: Johnny Mnemonic
Quoted from Vino:I’m easily confused and ready to vote.
Levi for Senate!!!
Not till after Kavanagh is confirmed at least.
Most Overrated: The Simpsons Pinball Party
Most Underrated: Gottlieb's Circus--for all the love given to Genie, the layout is similar yet it seems like it's not as common to find. I enjoy the game.
Most Overpriced: All of those System 11's that bring $3,500+
Best Value: Early solid state games that the kiddos don't pay attention to since they're down in the 200's in Pinside's ratings list or lacking enough votes to be ranked.
Quoted from jawjaw:Most Over Rated - pins I don't like
Most Under Rated - pins I own
Most Over Priced Pinball - pins I want to buy
Best Value - free pins
NAILED IT! 
Wanna join the discussion? Please sign in to reply to this topic.
Great to see you're enjoying Pinside! Did you know Pinside is able to run without any 3rd-party banners or ads, thanks to the support from our visitors? Please consider a donation to Pinside and get anext to your username to show for it! Or better yet, subscribe to Pinside+!
This page was printed from https://pinside.com/pinball/forum/topic/most-over-rated-most-under-rated-most-over-priced-best-value?hl=dkjimbo and we tried optimising it for printing. Some page elements may have been deliberately hidden.
Scan the QR code on the left to jump to the URL this document was printed from.
Milwaukee, WI
Gilligan's Island