Title doesn't say it all. What qualities are important to you? If you want a simple game anyone can get to the wizard mode to in less than a month with familiar characters it's #monsterbash by a mile. If you want a challenge with deep rules and modes you're not likely to see with a year of frequent play then Metallica (Pro) by a mile. Do you like campy humor and talking monsters or good callouts by members of Metallica? Do you want to have a great game and 4k in your bank account too? Metallica by a mile.