I haven't got the play GOT yet...so I can't really compare it yet. I know everyone is really disappointed in the artwork of GOT in general but I'll wait and see before commenting. I didn't think the artwork was very good for The Shadow either but it is still a great game to play. I have played TH at several shows and I own a MMRE and love it. Both are great games. Bottom line...I'd rather play them than rank them.