Quoted from jrcmlc:Is there a no bs comparison opinion available between the remake and OG? I thought I had a really nice OG bought, but that went to crap, so exploring all options.
(This is from a while back but maybe it'll help... this is from before MMR had the XL display, RGB GI and the topper too)
I know you weren't asking me, but I'll chime in... I had a MM for a couple years that I replaced with an MMR... the MM wasn't actually mine, but I'm gonna refer to it as "mine" to keep this simple.
Ramps are easier to make on MMR... fresh flippers and clearcoat make a big difference I'd imagine.
The drawbridge is ALOT quieter on my MMR than my MM. But again, it's like 20 years newer.
LED lighting is BRIGHT and looks great. The "Hi Res" color display is a plus, although the ColorDMD on my MM was just fine.
CGC options menu gives you some extra tuning options (all mine are still default) plus you have all the original Williams options.
The flipper travel is different than it was on my MM but I recently played another MM that was actually very close to my MM in terms of flipper travel and feel, so I assume my MMR is actually probably more "correct" than my MM was.
My MM was certainly more "dialed in", but I haven't had to much time on dialing in the MMR as it already plays so damn nice. It was alot easier to kill castles tho on my old MM than on my MMR tho so my scores were better, but I find myself getting to (and beating) Royal Madness alot more on MMR and completing more of the objectives like Master of Trolls, Patron of the Peasants, etc... (I did eventually get to and beat Battle for the Kingdom on my MMR)
Anyhow, I really like MMR. It feels like a "real" MM to me, but new.