I have a Whirlwind, Rifle Game, PinchHitter, Multi-Arcade, shuffleboard table and a Bally Wizard!. Since I got the Whirlwind, my wife refuses to play the Wizard! I like it well enough but space is such that I will be switching it out for something else. Not sure what to get, we went to a place this week that has a lot of A-list games. So we played a couple games on most of them. Here is what we discovered. Now please remember, the point was to eliminate as many as possible so our reactions may well have been a result of setup. Given that there is no other place locally to try these out, we are going to live with our snap judgments. TAF too damn dark, may well have been setup but the older one gets the more light one needs to see. Couldn't see a damn thing, including the ball. RFM (I really, really wanted to like this one) Wife thought it was too small. The size and height of the machine made it uncomfortable for me to play. JP, wow I literally thought I was going to have a seizure with the lights flashing directly into my face. No good. IJ was OK.
TZ also dark but was pretty fun and looked like it would have a lot to do, so it is in the running. MB was also fun, in the mix. GB (the standard) brutally fast drains but well lit and seemed fun. MM was the favorite (I don't know if this was original or remake). Probably the result of longer ball times and the feeling that you actually accomplished something like destroying the castle or smacking the trolls made it the favorite. However, given the amount of $ I will be shelling out (not expecting Wizard to make much of a dent in the cost), I would like to reduce the risk of buying something we won't like.
Another game on our list was WOZ. It seems like it might be fun and a thematic fit with Whirlwind (not that that matters beyond a possible tiebreaker) However, no place close by to try it, so I have no first-hand comments. Alas if we go in this direction it will be a roll of the dice.
Questions. First, neither my wife nor I are fans of long ball times (insert middle school joke here... I'll defer as it is too easy) In fact on one of the MM games I somehow managed to get a ton of points winning a credit and earning an extra ball. I let my wife play my extra ball because it felt like it was getting a bit long. Now the occasional long ball is fine, but I don't want a game where one can expect 5-10 minute ball times as typical. On the other hand, GB had a good number of really, really fast drains. I've read that the premium is a bit smoother and more interesting to play, so if there is a significant difference in play between the two, that would be good to know. We'd like a game with a lot of things to do but don't need a really deep, thinking man's game. Basically, would like a game where we can pop down stairs and play 4-5 games in a 1 -1.5 hours or so.
So, given the list of games I listed above, what are your thoughts/recommendations?