This is an awesome idea Hilton! I love it. What a great way to get people energized, have some fun, and get some rare games to MGC. Nice work! Kudos also to Vidgameseller for bringing such a great game.
As some others have stated, I really would consider setting some type of rule set to the definition of "rare", if anything just to make the category more real and genuine toward what you're tying to accomplish. I have a Hook with a NOS clearcoated playfield. I'm pretty sure i'm the only one, or at least among the very few, to have spent the money on that game. It's a rare game then (?) , but not what I would say is in the spirit of what your attempting. Right? I think you should exclude games like that, as there are existing award categories that those could fit into if people really wanted it to win. I would highlight the games like Goin Nuts that are truly rare. My opinion though...
I suppose just letting people drop quarters as they see fit is fine, but after years of tallying votes for the Best in Show awards, I can honestly say there may be a few logistical issues with that - not to mention the EM issue that was brought up. You're likely to see a ton of quarters dropped into non-rare games... or the Pac-Man upright in the corner. That might be fine, this being all in good fun, but you'll have a lot of 1 vote games and the like. You may find it difficult to track everyone down and count those votes right at the start of the party when everyone is racing toward food and drink. Regardless, I love the coin idea should you be able to iron all that out.
What do you think about combining this with the existing Best In Show awards in some way...perhaps just as an appendix, perhaps as a complete redesign of the whole process...but all in an attempt to assure folks can easily distinguish between all the categories we have today, and the ones you're creating?
We should connect on this. You've got a good idea here and I think we can incorporate this into the show and the existing award process to step it up a bit. Worth discussing at least??
Aaron