I've done several hardtops and now two playfield swaps to CPRs....Meteor was my first, and I just completed a Night Rider playfield swap a couple months ago (working on the cabinet now).
I've gotten over my fear of drilling into a brand new playfield. Once I got by that, the only real fear that lingers is the tediousness of removing the playfield harness and tracking every single point where you're desoldering so that you can correctly solder things back up. That requires a TON of pictures and (at least for me) toe-tagging each connection point and zip typing the tags to the wires.
In for a penny, in for a pound, right? So with the harness removed, you've got to clean it as you'll likely never have that opportunity again. And as long as the playfield mechs are now unencumbered by wires and you have to remove those as well to move them to their new home, you might as well tear them down and clean those, too. If you don't, you'll regret putting parts and wires with 30-40 years of dirt, grime, and black coil dust on a brand, new shiny CPR playfield.
As previous posters said, don't trust the dimples on a CPR playfield. They're great as a guideline, but there will always be ones that are off. From my vast experience of doing this twice, lol:
Meteor
- Two dimples were missing topside (for posts) on my edition of the CPR. Unlike the underside, you have to be careful drilling new holes thru the topside clearcoat to avoid cracking. Plenty of videos on youtube show you how this is done and what tools to use.
- At least 20 dimples on the underside were off, a few by a lot. Best advice is to line up your hardware with where it needs to be, hold it in place (a second set of hands is handy at this point), and use an awl to make your own dimple for pre-drilling. This is made somewhat easier by using a playfield rotisserie.
- Three of the drop target banks (111, 222, 333) where a cinch - got those in and working the first time. The METEOR drop target bank was a hot mess. I probably drilled holes, filled in holes, and redrilled holes 3 or 4 times to get the right position for that bank (along with rebuilding and adjusting the assembly multiple times) so that the targets dropped and reset properly.
Night Rider
- Topside dimples good!
- Pretty much every dimple was off on the underside, but it may not totally be CPR's fault. The Night Rider CPR playfield is for the SS version of the pin, and I'm restoring the EM version. So I pretty much had to make my own underside dimples anyway because the wire harnesses for the SS and EM versions are vastly different, of course. And there are extra EM mechs on the underside as well.