Throwing this out just for fun and for comments. I'm replacing a song on Metallica again and have a few choices shown below.
Unforgiven was replaced already with a covers medley of Last Caress/Green Hell/Too Late Too Late. Worked good because I have to fit the song into the 6'26" slot of Unforgiven. Each song also has to work at the 15" mark because that begins playing at the end of each game. Also has to work at the 3'40" mark because that begins playing when entering your name for a high score. My wife just doesn't like Too Late and even though the other songs work in the spots, especially Last Caress, I just want to go with a single song in this slot.
Here's the choices that I like so far and will work in the slot.
Broken Beaten & Scarred
Sabbra Cadabra (I really like as a fun pinball song, but does drag in the middle)
The Thing That Should Not Be
Welcome Home (Sanitarium)