Quoted from xeneize:skins What was your approach for recreating these? Did you scan and clean up, or were they available for download somewhere? Thanks!
http://www.pinballrebel.com/pinball/cards/
Download and email the file to a local print place (I have used FedEx Office Print & Ship Center) and tell them to print them out on "card stock"! Your printer may be able to print card stock so that would be first thing to check!