I went through the same debate. MB is an all-time classic for a reason.
But with MB, you know what’s going to happen when you hit the start button. With Elvira, the game is evolving. It’s a new experience. Updates are dropping all the time.
If you want tried and true, go MB. Can’t go wrong. But if you want to take the journey, go Elvira. With Lyman as your captain, you’re guaranteed a fun ride.