Quoted from Zitt:From where I stood; this was stolen property.
And it was theft.
You just reacted too quick on this Zitt. There was no sign of theft whatsoever especially when you looked and they had no inventory of said item. An easy phone call, which is what resolved this situation, would've resolved this without the public bashing.
I know Marco wouldn't pursue this but if it were someone else, it wouldn't be surprise if they went after you legally for slander!