(Topic ID: 255483)

The Mandolorian by Disney, discussions, contain SPOILERS this topic does

By Atari_Daze

4 years ago


Topic Heartbeat

Topic Stats

  • 606 posts
  • 108 Pinsiders participating
  • Latest reply 3 years ago by wesman
  • Topic is favorited by 11 Pinsiders

You

Topic poll

“The Mandolorian by Disney, discussions, contain SPOILERS this topic does”

  • I will continue to watch 110 votes
    87%
  • Meh, doesn't peak my interest 16 votes
    13%

(126 votes)

Topic Gallery

View topic image gallery

7f587e19ef11b268 (resized).jpg
ryan-gosling-laughing-oscars-640x480 (resized).jpeg
2021.01.21-10.53-boundingintocomics-600a05e97cd6a (resized).jpg
2021.01.21-11.35-boundingintocomics-600a0fa9eb8c4 (resized).jpg
HTD9gEl (resized).jpg
85EA7CB3-0E21-486C-8178-DAB0BD3E934E.gif
Screenshot_20201215-140643 (resized).png
132135393_3618703148206427_8800067857665574212_n (resized).jpg
1152181 (resized).jpg
FE172DCC-5B46-4E60-B0F2-4EAC2B9DD13B (resized).jpeg
pasted_image (resized).png
pasted_image (resized).png
pasted_image (resized).png
pasted_image (resized).png
pasted_image (resized).png
Starship-Boca-Chica-120320-Richard-Angle-SN8-pad-build-site-overview-sunset-1-crop-1-c-c-2048x738 (resized).jpg

You're currently viewing posts by Pinsider forceflow.
Click here to go back to viewing the entire thread.

#23 4 years ago
Quoted from Methos:

It was ok. Agree with the Western motif, although it was interesting how the payment was a actually a metal to be used as part of his uniform

Beskar ore (an indestructible iron ore) was famous for being used in Mandalorian armor, and the only place it came from was the Mandalorian homeworld. Mandalore was occupied by the Empire for many years, and after the Empire fell, Beskar became very valuable to the Mandalorians as they started to rebuild. The old Imperial who hired the bounty hunter in the show probably obtained a stockpile of it sometime during the occupation, and/or after the Empire fell.

Quoted from benheck:

Thought it did an excellent job making the characters immediately likeable though I was sad to see the Droid die.

I thought it was pretty cool to see an IG droid in action, after only seeing it briefly in ESB and a few comic book panels.

Quoted from benheck:

Thought - the early scene where he won't take a shiny Droid vehicle and instead wants a human driving a POS - was that an Uber vs Cabs reference I wonder?

Mandalorians didn't have a cultural aversion to droids from what I recall. However, from a practical standpoint, droids can be reprogrammed and hijacked. A real pilot can be leveraged/threatened if they're compromised to act against their passenger.

#28 4 years ago
Quoted from Pinmeister:

I’ve had as much Star Wars as I can take.

Bad star wars, you mean?

Quoted from Pinmeister:

Bring back Firefly,

That would be great

Probably impossible at this point, though. Everybody is on other projects. Incidently, The Rookie has been pretty good so far.

1 week later
#126 4 years ago
Quoted from HoakyPoaky:

The baby can simply be another individual from his race. The connection to Yoda isn't necessary. The mystery centers around their race, where they came from, why they are so force sensitive, why the Empire loyalists are after it, who wants it dead, etc etc etc. Linking to Yoda would tie the writers down I think.

From what I recall, Lucas was intentionally keeping Yoda (& Yaddle's) backgrounds and species a mystery.

I'm guessing Disney wants to change that, considering the introduction of this new baby Yoda character.

2 weeks later
#205 4 years ago
Quoted from John_I:

Funny everyone has their own opinions... I like the Mandalorian, but can't stand the Watchmen. I stopped watching that one after three episodes.

I like the Mandalorian so far.

I agree on the Watchmen. I saw one episode and it was a complete turn off for me. I get why it may have been important to the story, but it's not something I enjoy to see in my downtime.

#239 4 years ago
Quoted from Beatnik-Filmstar:

but it's still baffling that they still had nothing ready to go 7 months after the movie was released.

Merchandising was a pretty new concept back then. That's why when Fox funded the movie, they weren't interested in merchandising and instead went for the distribution rights of the movie.

Today, merchandising is a huge piece of the pie.

#241 4 years ago
Quoted from Rdoyle1978:

I'm not the hugest Disney fan, and I did feel really burned

I agree--I think Disney really botched things. I really expected more from them.

Dropping all the expanded universe material like it didn't matter, and then with Kathleen Kennedy recently saying "we have no source material" is kind of a slap in the face. I have bookshelves full of 40 years worth of star wars books. That is a heck of a lot of source material right there. Not to mention all the decades of comic books and video games out there. There is an incredible abundance of source material. Even if you can't use the original trilogy characters, there are plenty of side stories and pre/post trilogy adventures to explore and expand upon, as well as fascinating characters.

Quoted from Rdoyle1978:

and Rogue One, which I still feel is the best recent SW movie

I agree--I've re-watched it a few times and liked it for the most part, but do have some issues with it. Some of the contemporary moments/dialog that get shoehorned in kind of remove me from the moment.

The others (TFA, TLJ, and Solo) I haven't had a huge desire to see more than twice.

I think with a solid team of fans without much corporate involvement would have resulted in something much better. Some of the fan fiction films out there that I've seen are incredibly creative and often times left me wanting more.

With Disney's treatment of the films, I haven't really been left wanting more. I don't have high hopes for the latest film.

At least with the Mandalorian, it returns to exploring an interesting area of Star Wars lore. Which is what Disney should've done in the first place.

#269 4 years ago
Quoted from northvibe:

Ha he reminded me of the bad guy in the matrix that turns on the crew.

That's Joe Pantoliano, who played Cypher.

#296 4 years ago
Quoted from gdonovan:

Act I has established the Manodlorian character and motivations to some degree, the Mcguffin has been introduced (The Child) and the dilemma.. From there the story arc has effectively stalled and turned into adventure of the week.

I agree--there was the goal of rescuing the the child, getting away, and then the main plot kind of stopped developing there. The child mainly turned into a side curiosity after that the other characters occasionally encountered.

I was hoping to see some more development since it started as the big plot point.

Even with the adventure of the week, I would have liked to see something worked in where the Mandalorian needed to get something or go somewhere to move the plot forward. Right now, it's just aimless wandering.

11 months later
#443 3 years ago
Quoted from Rdoyle1978:

REALLY liked TFA. A lot. Then TLJ and the next one just didn't follow ANY of the story I was hoping for and I totally lost interest. Thought Finn would be a great unfound jedi. Nope. Instead we got Grampa Clone Palpatine and just a ton of crap we'd seen before (after TFA I figured they would try to be more original). Dont think I ever got over how they just totally blew it with Luke either.

I think Rogue One was the only new film that had any sort of coherent story. The others were a mess and just basically made up things on the fly. There were some good visuals and interesting sequences, but those don't really seem to make up for all the other problems.

I've enjoyed the mandalorian so far, but my only minor criticism from this latest episode was that the stormtroopers basically acted like untrained circus clowns. I would have expected them to display a bit more tactical awareness, even if they can't hit the broad side of a barn door. I'm guessing that stormtroopers who survived the fall of the empire probably didn't make it out of that without some skills to show for it.

#449 3 years ago
Quoted from gdonovan:

I thought you could chop half the story out and no one would even notice, there were plot holes you could drive a bus through.

There were certainly a lot of problems with it, but far less than the other films. When it first came out, I didn't like it a whole lot, but then when placed against the other films, I liked it a bit more since the others were so bad.

One thing about the new films is that I cringe every time there is a contemporary reference or use of a contemporary word/phrase in a star wars movie. They just sound so jarring and out of place in that universe.

That's not a problem with the Mandalorian--there's hardly any lines, lol

#452 3 years ago
Quoted from Rdoyle1978:

I watched the behind the scenes thing about Mandalorian and you can tell Favreau is a MEGA fan. He gets so psyched just talking about getting the 70s look and the “worn future” aesthetic right. Him and Filoni are a great team. I have so much more respect for those guys protecting this like Lucas would.

I saw an interview with Filoni a few months back--he talked about star wars on a much deeper level than anybody I've heard from before, and pointed out a lot of interesting things that I never realized before. It was really interesting--and refreshing that someone involved in creating live action star wars content cared so much about it. He certainly has quite a lot of passion for star wars.

#456 3 years ago
Quoted from zombywoof:

HAN SHOT FIRST, FOR CRYING OUT LOUD!

pasted_image (resized).pngpasted_image (resized).png
#462 3 years ago
Quoted from Rdoyle1978:

On the other hand, they should be no match for 2 Mandalorian-ish dudes and a cyborg bounty Hunter.

That shouldn't have stopped them from at least trying to establish a defensible position instead of just standing out in the open without any sort of formation.

These were supposed to be Moff Gideon's troops. In season one, they seemed to be reasonably competent as far as OT stormtroopers go, not to mention outfitted with good, clean, and serviced equipment (unlike the old imperial client's stormtroopers from season 1).

Anyway....that doesn't stop me from looking forward to the next episode.

#466 3 years ago
Quoted from Rdoyle1978:

Not really disagreeing - but I am not sure they were Moff Gideon’s troops. I didn’t get the impression they were his personal guard or anything (in the first season, those guys were the 501st! Just saw that awesome BTS episode)
I figured they were just a run of the mill battalion. Still, dumbness in the field haha

It looked like they were in drop ships that came down from Gideon's cruiser. It seemed like they were his troops, but like you say, not his personal guard.

#484 3 years ago
Quoted from Oaken:

At least it was purposeful and it wasn’t game of thrones oopsie coffee cup level

They did have "jeans guy" in the background of one scene. It was trending for a bit, then disney erased him.
pasted_image (resized).pngpasted_image (resized).png

pasted_image (resized).pngpasted_image (resized).png
#487 3 years ago
Quoted from Indypin:

the same actor who played the evil Winter King in Game of Thrones

He (Richard Brake) also had a significant role in Doom.

#492 3 years ago
Quoted from Pickle:

I caught that.....pretty cheesy but good for a laugh...it’s like watching to see how many Easter eggs/ references you can catch in each episode. Keeps it a little interesting as long as it’s subtle.

I still think contemporary references have no place in star wars. It's like breaking the 4th wall. It just doesn't work for the material.

#515 3 years ago
Quoted from Methos:

I don't know, having the she warriors all march Rambo style straight down a hall without any over, and without getting hit once seems like it's violating physics a bit....just sayin. But overall, you're dead on.

It's the superhero advance. Or the Mario invincibility star.

I'm not really bothered by it since it's just part of the action.

#542 3 years ago
Quoted from gdonovan:

The first movie out of the box should have been Luke Skywalker doing badass Jedi stuff mopping up the Empire or tangling with Thrawn.

This. There were a lot of good stories and characters in the EU that disney decided to throw away to allow what they so-called "creative freedom". Ugh.

That doesn't mean everything in the EU was perfect--there is some clunky stuff with rough edges in the mix.

But the point is that there was plenty of room in the EU for new stories that don't have to be directly connected to the main characters of the OT, as The Mandalorian has proven. Disney didn't need to throw away the EU to make room for the really clunky, unplanned, uneven, and very rough cornerstone films they put out. They would've been better served following or fitting into existing EU stories that already had a roadmap in place, rather than making something up quite literally on the fly. If disney really wanted "creative freedom" they could have just done some other new space opera where there were no established rules or characters to contend with.

#560 3 years ago
132135393_3618703148206427_8800067857665574212_n (resized).jpg132135393_3618703148206427_8800067857665574212_n (resized).jpg
#561 3 years ago
Screenshot_20201215-140643 (resized).pngScreenshot_20201215-140643 (resized).png

You're currently viewing posts by Pinsider forceflow.
Click here to go back to viewing the entire thread.

Reply

Wanna join the discussion? Please sign in to reply to this topic.

Hey there! Welcome to Pinside!

Donate to Pinside

Great to see you're enjoying Pinside! Did you know Pinside is able to run without any 3rd-party banners or ads, thanks to the support from our visitors? Please consider a donation to Pinside and get anext to your username to show for it! Or better yet, subscribe to Pinside+!


This page was printed from https://pinside.com/pinball/forum/topic/mandolorian-by-disney-thoughts-discussions?tu=forceflow and we tried optimising it for printing. Some page elements may have been deliberately hidden.

Scan the QR code on the left to jump to the URL this document was printed from.