Quoted from pinballcorpse:So now let's look at Avengers. (I am not a rule expert on this pin, but I have played it more than 3 times ). Black Widow is satisfying-when it is made. I see lots of bricked shots on this ramp (others and me included) and it takes a lot of shots to get things going. It is not backhand friendly (can be done here and there, but don't count on it).
That saucer in the upper left part of the playfield is either hit and hope or again hit a tight shot on the Black Widow ramp. Loki/Hawkeye is tight as well, but very makeable. (As I mentioned earlier this is probably the safest shot on the game and the employed strategy for many). The Iron Man and Captain America shots are also tight. Yes they can all be made, but that is not the point.
In X-Men and Avengers there is not much for casual players to stumble into-certainly not a casual player/owner of a 6-7K pin. (Disclosure: I own X-MenLE and I personally enjoy it, but IMO it really is not new/casual player friendly). That is a key area where games like X-Men and Avengers struggle IMO. (Another quick aside: I love TFLE and it suffers some of this as well-either a player is hitting things dead on or they are in trouble).
Ok so the BW ramp is very tight. But there is plenty here for a novice player. Bashing hulk a few times will qualify hulk mb and random shots up the middle will eventually start it. Bashing the cube will start some neat light show effects as tesseract mode starts. It will also light extra ball. The hawkeye ramp is probably the easiest shot in the game of the main shots. Shoot this a few times and Loki mb starts. There's a lot more going on here for a novice player than xmen.
The right side is very difficult. Both BW and ironman. The other oddity in this game is that the location of right side shots is slightly off from any other game. Walking up to this game that I've played hundreds of times, it still takes me a good three games to readjust to these shot locations. But once adjusted I can flow the BW ramp in succession. I think the adjustment to the shot locations makes a decent player think they'll never hit the shots and lose interest. It's unfortunate but untrue.
As for enjoyment, I think I enjoy my avengers more than my xmen and definitely more than my acdc. And if a new player "flails" (as you said) on acdc they get one reward - the outlanes.