I can't really answer which will be better for you. For me, I have owned LOTR and enjoyed it for a few months. I did grow tired of it, sold it and have not missed it at all. There is something about flow disruption and overuse of the POTD that kills that game for me at this point. On the other hand I have only ever played GOT a few times and I love Steve Ritchie, so the choice for me would be easy. I would go with GOT by default.