Have an opportunity to trade my LOTR for a POTC. For argument sake lets assume that the games are equal in condition. As it seems as they are based on pics. A straight up trade, one for the other, is the deal that would be made. Want to know how they stack up against each other. Would you trade a LOTR for a POTC straight up? How do they compare gameplay wise? Does POTC compare in price for a LOTR? Is POTC just as fun? I love my LOTR, but with my small gameroom, its time to mix it up, and my son is a huge pirates fan, so I know he would love it. I have only played this game once and it was at Disney world. Any advice on how they compare in gameplay, price wise would be appreciated! Thanks!!

I do have more than one. I also have a TRON from the February release. Thats not going anywhere any time soon. Have played my LOTR enough to where I am ready for a new one. To mix it up a bit. I don't have the funds to purchase another machine...so one has to go...and its gotta be LOTR, cause TRON is just awesome! I was planning on getting rid of it anyway soon to fund the new star trek... but that's awhile out yet.

Could u explain what u mean? Is it just not as fun? Not as deep? I understand the depth of LOTR... but I like that my son plays my pins too, and LOTR has been played enough by us that I just feel its time to mix it up a bit. Something fresh. We have pretty much stopped playing it. I play it maybe 2 times a week now? My son loves pirates...and I know he would love it. I only have room for 2 pins, so the LOTR has just been played out by both of us. So basically looking for a comparable, fin game that has a good theme

Thanks everyone for their advice. It is much appreciated!

Lastly...as for price. I had estimated my LOTR based on condition and mods added at 5000$. The guy that has the Potc says its in awesome shape...huo...just shopped out...etc. I have seen pics and have no reason to doubt it. and he values it at 5000 as well. That is why we are wanting to do a trade straight up. Without pics and info above...is 5000 fair value for Potc?

His Potc has recently been thoroughly shopped.. new rubber...waxed...etc. has new compass decal and black pearl cannon mod. Nothing else done to it. Pics of it are very clean and solid. One edge of the right outlane plastic is broke off...but everything else is solid. No pf wear...no cab damage at all.

My LOTR is not huo I am guessing as it has a carriage bolt on front by coin door. Has normal wear on metal ramps, couple cracked plastics but not noticeable. I have added fro do shooter rod...plastic protectors... gold flipper buttons...upgraded flipper coils...crystal ball palantir mod with color change led...potd mod...target decals...speaker light kit with one ring gold inserts...Arwen diverted plastic..cliffy protectors...orthsnc rebound protector...colored incandescent lights in key areas..mirror blades (but thinking of keeping these to put on Potc )
Had some wear spots on cab but was able to mostly cover using gold and black paint pen.

All in all, my LOTR has more mods...but his Potc is in general better overall condition.