Quoted from Prosedsp:This was it! Replaced the Balrog wires and it started working. Thanks guys!
I have a similar but different problem with the Balrog. My flasher doesn't work and I've traced it to the orange (hot) wire inside the bundle. Oddly enough the bundle for the flasher has two larger gauge wires and two smaller gauge wires, the former being used for the flasher. The switch uses the striped wires. Both connect to the IDC connector under the playfield.
My follow-up question is -- did you just remove the wires from the IDC connector and then force new wires down into it? IIRC there is a special tool to put wires in IDC connectors. Is there something (like a screwdriver) that will work in lieu of the tool?